It Gets Worse: Does this story sound familiar? The National Council of Churches in the Philippines (NCCP) said church leaders speaking out against society’s ills does not violate the principle of separation of Church and State. Since their religious position is none of the government’s concern but rather the allegations of what, in secular society we would normally call “kidnapping” and “plunder” instead of “illegal detention” and “gross misuse of funds” actually are. The doctrine of separation of Church and State however operates more as a restriction on the powers of the State or the government than on the Church. Medieval nga daw diba. Wikipedia defines bangsamoro as a "religious group" by calling them non-Catholics. Is divorce immoral? Your email address will not be published. That’s right: he changed religions. There is a saying that goes “Render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s, and unto God the things that are God’s.” The practice of ordination or excommunication, both big deals in most religions, are out of the jurisdiction of the government, no matter how sexist (any female priests lately?) Muralla cor Recoletos Sts. With the ridiculous mass of people in EDSA supposedly fighting for “Separation of Church and State” amid an impending investigation into potentially criminal activities involving a certain church’s leadership, it has been easy to point and laugh at their gross misunderstanding of this inviolable right granted unto us by the 1987 constitution. The non-establishment of a state religion is in place to assure us that religious leaders do not have the kind of power they had during the medieval ages. Kel Fabie. 178. The free exercise and enjoyment of religious profession and worship, without discrimination or preference, shall forever be allowed. Christmas trees in City Hall? Input your search keywords and press Enter. 1 talking about this. (Article II, Section 6), and, No law shall be made respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. Moderator:PDFF Mod Group. As defined by Wikipedia: "The Moro people or Bangsamoro are a population of indigenous Muslims in the Philippines, forming the largest non-Catholic group in the country, and comprising about 5% of the total Philippine population." 15 posts 1; 2; Next; Separation of Church and State Separation of Church and State. “The separation of Church and State shall be inviolable.” (Article III, Section 5) This is written in our 1987 Constitution. A church as a unit but a bunch of private individuals when apart, it isn’t exactly possible to insist that the church not have a say in the affairs of the state, so while reprehensible since it leads to politicians figuratively (I think) getting into bed with religious leaders just to gain their endorsement, its just like feudalism all over again. They cannot practice this and then ignore the rights of other people to practice differently. Debunking 8 Disingenuous Arguments Against the SOGIE Bill, Debunking 8 Bad-Faith Arguments About Racism (That Won’t Make Your Momma Proud), Today in ‘Nobody Asked for This’: DENR Is Planning to Turn Manila Bay Shores into White Sand Beaches, 8 Reasons “Not Nice Thing I Did In College” Deserves a Closer Look, Here Are Some of the Best SONA 2020 Tweets That Will Make You Laugh. Got me thinking. Massive tarps with politician’s faces wishing the Iglesia a happy 10X’th anniversary? The Angelus being blared on the PA for a government office? Swearing on a Bible in a trial? Meanwhile, any law that might privilege other religions over others will continue going unchecked. Joaquin Bernas, a Filipino Jesuit specializing in constitutional law, acknowledges that there were complex issues that were brought to court and numerous attempts to use the “separation of Church and State” against … MANAGING THE SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE AND RELIGIOUS FREEDOM by: HILARIO G. DAVIDE, JR. * Introduction & Executive Summary Religion has always been an important aspect of Filipino life. Evident of this assumption is the issue of RH Bill which the church vehemently opposes. While the principle honors distinctions between temporal and spiritual functions, both Church and State maintain a unique and cooperative relationship geared towards the common good. He has an Oscar, a Pulitzer, a Nobel, and two other weirdly-named pet dogs. It Gets Worse: Religious freedom means one is free to believe or not to believe in what they want. Muslims are not indigenous people. Because bloc voting, which we’ll get into in a bit. “Besides, to paraphrase what Bishop Broderick Pabillo stated, as citizens and rights holders, members of the clergy also have rights to call to task the government, the duty bearers, if they are remiss in their duties and responsibilities to the people,” added Marigza. Should We Be Calling for an Academic Freeze Instead of Resuming Classes in August. 178. Why, because it now works to their advantage to do so, even if they used a very misguided reading of the provision to do it. Share. The separation of church and state is a philosophic and jurisprudential concept for defining political distance in the relationship between religious organizations and the state. Separation of church and state in the Philippines: lt;p|>|Freedom of religion in the Philippines| is guaranteed by the |Constitution of the Philippi... World Heritage Encyclopedia, the aggregation of the largest online encyclopedias available, and the most definitive collection ever assembled. If for some reason, we would elect a president who turned out to be, say, a Satanist, do you think that the CBCP would let him express his religion in public the way they encouraged it when GMA used to do this all the time for photo ops? Not necessarily. Most of us are guilty of not understanding the implications of a genuine separation between church and state. Article II, Section 6 states, “The separation of the Church and the State shall be inviolable.” Article III, Section 5 states, “No law shall be made respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. Making concessions for a visiting Pope? But separated from politics and the entanglements of politicians, the church should be and ought to be. The (insert obscure religion here)? Member. and is an abrogation of a person’s rights. If a government employee uses their personal money to buy a rosary, where’s the harm? … Any chance people can understand that distinction? Your email address will not be published. But when the government spends taxpayer money to favor a particular religion or another, that’s questionable, because where is the spending on Rizalistas? Is it wrong? It Gets Worse: If Separation of Church and State has been functionally ignored for decades by the Philippines, why is the INC protesting it only now? Such as the case of the Death Penalty, the State wants to have it returned, but the Church has contradicted it multiple times. The nation heard the phrase "Separation of Church and State" several times in the past days. We still have our limits (I hope). And hey, most of us reading this right now aren’t Muslims, right? The Philippines, consistent with the national interest, adopts and pursues a policy of … It also helps our respective flocks in their reflection and discernment”, the NCCP leader said. It basically states that the church, or any religious organizations for that matter, and the government should leave each other alone. 1 talking about this. The INC leadership are reading from the exact same playbook the ADD leadership was when they insisted the late former Justice Secretary Raul Gonzales was persecuting them when he took an interest in the allegations of rape against Brother Eli Soriano. And if not laws, how about…. STATE POLICIES. Observing these things and pointing them out to be allegations that are actionable are the rights of anyone, yet somehow, because religion is involved, these people suddenly become untouchable and irreproachable. Required fields are marked *. If you truly believe in the inherent merit of Separation of Church and State, then know one thing: we have a long way to go to actually having it. In its relations with other states, the paramount consideration shall be national sovereignty, territorial integrity, national interest, and the right to self-determination. Where does that leave everybody else, no matter how minor? Unfortunately, this rare moment where we can flaunt our apparent moral ascendancy in this matter does not necessarily mean we are that much better. In the Philippines, it’s just separation of (Catholic) church and state. Was De Lima investigating this case “selective?” I wouldn’t know, but that’s the point. Separation of Church and State means that when this call was made, whoever organized this demonstration is guilty of sedition, and the subsequent demonstration has to be dispersed. Intramuros, Manila 1002 I get that. Also not illegal, if only the FCC would let him be. For the first time since 1898, the new Constitution included the “separation of Church and State” clause, signaling a new development in the body of law on religious affairs (Sison 5). Bishop Reuel Norman O. Marigza, general secretary of the NCCP, said it is the moral duty of every Christian, especially church leaders, to announce and denounce the ills of society. Why do only select religions get this special treatment? Know what our Philippine Constitution says about the Separation of Church and State and not the one peddled by online trolls: 1) The separation between Church & State shall be inviolable. Do some research about what happened in medieval age about catholicism. Just a Filipino citizen with the same rights and freedoms as every other Filipino citizen. We are a secular government governed by laws held in common for Filipinos regardless of creed or lack of it. No atheist. allegations of rape against Brother Eli Soriano. In theory, it should all work out for the best but we all know that’s not the case. Manila bishop dares Panelo: File case if we violated separation of Church and State Katrina Domingo, ABS-CBN News Updated as of Jul 20 03:40 PM Manila Auxiliary Bishop Broderick Pabillo on Monday dared a Palace official to file charges against Roman Catholic leaders after allegations that the Philippines' dominant religion violated a Constitutionally-mandated separation between the Church and … Also regarding family planning, the Church and the State always don’t see eye to eye. Muslims belong to the religion of Islam. Sounds familiar? The same goes for law enforcement agencies who might have reason to work on these issues. A misguided rally in EDSA is not going to solve anything for us. The provision of the 1987 Philippine Constitution regarding the separation of church and state was patterned after the abovementioned provision in the US Constitution. The religious are privileged in status in that the norm follows their common practices so much that when other people call attention to it being actually discriminatory in their favor, they cry “persecution” instead of recognizing it for what it truly is: a call for equal treatment for everyone in the eyes of the law. Well, technically the Church and the State are separated, but since the Philippines is a mostly Catholic country, the Church has a huge influence on how the State is run. Article II, Section 6 of the Philippine Constitution declares that: “The separation of Church and State shall be inviolable.” Throughout the history of our country, countless religious figures held great roles in driving the political direction of our elected leaders. Remind yourself what Freddie Aguilar did in 2013 when, at the time, he couldn’t legally marry his 16-year old girlfriend. All of these arguments have been nothing but a showcase in the many ways the constitutional provision of Separation of Church and State has been nothing more than a joke in this country, and it is only ever brought up as an issue when people’s privilege on the matter is challenged. It’s not about what happened to PH when being colonized by Spaniards. (Art II, Sec 6, of the Philippine Constitution) 2) Government is prohibited from preventing people in the free exercise of their religion. Share your opinion in the comments section below! The Scientologists? Section 6. illegal detention and gross misuse of funds. So why are we making these concessions? © 2020 Manila Bulletin The Nation's Leading Newspaper. In its declaration of principles, the 1987 Philippine Constitution provides for the separation of Church and State. He said it is actually the government who is not listening to its people as the Anti-Terrorism Act and the closure of ABS-CBN are overwhelmingly being criticized by various sectors of society. “This is what the prophets of old and Jesus Christ did during their respective times. [2031646,2581480,2581478,2581476,2581469,2581467,2581461], Speaking out not a violation of separation of Church, State — NCCP, Duterte okays 2-week extension of UK travel ban, Pilot implementation of face-to-face classes recalled — Briones, Traveler from UK who recently arrived in PH tests positive for COVID, 30 NPA fighters surrender in Agusan del Norte, 2 multi-purpose buildings completed in Zamboanga Del Norte for training — DPWH, Pa kills two kids on Christmas Day after wife commits suicide, Davao couple channels Adam & Eve in prenuptial shoot, Father nabbed for alleged sexual abuse of 4-yr-old daughter, Duterte wants experts to lead new task force vs new COVID-19 variant, Overhaul of national police system needed, farmers group tells Sinas, Duterte raises possibility of lockdown if new COVID-19 strain spreads in PH, Health protocols, travel restrictions must be strengthened as new COVID-19 strain confirmed in Sabah — Go, Duterte withdraws order allowing face-to-face classes in pilot areas due to new COVID-19 strain, Gatchalian: Spend money on food instead of firecrackers, Fil-British family arrives from Scotland, taken into quarantine, 2 LPAs moving closer to PH; rains forecast. Miserably. The separation of Church and State shall be inviolable. Is it evil? When a man decides to become a priest, he willingly cedes that right in the service of a perceived higher cause. It Gets Worse: The BBL is one of the things we need to bring peace to Mindanao. This is also why some sectors insist that it’s time the church started paying taxes, which is a topic for another day. Towards this end, the State is prohibited from favoring an official religion and, as a general rule, no public money shall be spent for a religious purpose. But it is a mistaken notion that needs to be challenged and corrected. No Iglesia. Manila Auxiliary Bishop Broderick Pabillo on Monday dared a Palace official to file charges against Roman Catholic leaders after allegations that the Philippines' dominant religion violated a Constitutionally-mandated separation between the Church and the State. Who does? Judd. They thereby manifested reliance upon Him who guides the destinies of men and nations Of course, the Sin that this writer is referring to is the late Jaime Cardinal Sin, who was one of the prime movers of People Power I that ousted the Marcos dictatorship. Yes, freedom of expression does not come with freedom from consequences, but when the government steps in to favor a religion at the expense of everyone else when the sensible solution was to not go to the exhibit that might offend you, it’s pretty clear that Separation of Church and State is a myth in this country. This definition contradicts itself. This very separation is why, if, say, gay marriage were made legal in the Philippines, religions need not worry about being forced to fall in line with this newly legalized practice. Despite that, if a religion happened to celebrate ritual human sacrifice, it’s pretty sure that such a practice being religious in nature will not protect it from prosecution. They can’t insist that their freedom should trump the freedom of other people, such that while Muslims may choose to not eat pork, Iglesias may choose to not eat dinuguan, and Catholics may abstain from meat on Fridays. All Rights Reserved. While there is some level of protection afforded the government by theoretical separation of State and Church, most of the protection is in favor of the Church, actually. Apparently, yes. The separation of church and state is a key constitutional liberty which protects the American public from tyranny. It is absolute. In short, walang basagan ng trip. The part where we give special rights to other people because they’re of a specific religion? PSA: It’s Nearly 2021 — Why Are People Still Body Shaming? When someone gets illegally detained, this happens against their will (why else would they sue?) Instead, they were handed a permit post hoc, which does not happen if, say, a labor group tried to pull the same stunt. Share with: Link: Copy link. It protects all people from the religious tyranny of any one religious group or tradition and it protects all people from a government intent on tyrannizing some or … supposedly the second coming of Christ himself, 8 Smart Ways to Spend Your 13th Month Pay This Year. Hold on a minute here. Ever since the the 20th century, the Catholic Church has been right-wing in trying to gain back the powers they lost when Spain lost to America. In its declaration of principles, the 1987 Philippine Constitution provides for the separation of Church and State. (Art III, Sec 5, of the Philippine Constitution) I wouldn’t go so far as to say that religions should be taxed, but as it stands, Separation of Church and State is already being ignored in ways very advantageous for religious organizations, such as the special consideration regarding marriage for our Muslim brothers. Does this really need to be explained? Do they not have the same rights to address their grievances? For example, the government can’t dictate who becomes church leaders to a given church, but the church can dictate to their flock who to vote for, and if the flock obeys, well, that’s just too bad for the candidates who didn’t curry the favor of the church in question. Just ask Mong Palatino, who tried really hard to make it happen and failed. The principle of separation of church and state has been much abused and misinterpreted (or rather interpreted for political ends) in the country, especially after the Sin of Edsa I. Your daily dose of entertaining, useful and informative lists. I agree with everything. The free exercise and enjoyment of religious profession and worship, without discrimination or preference, shall forever be allowed. Because morality, blah, Vatican, blah. It Gets Worse: Pastor Quiboloy endorsed Gibo Teodoro in 2010, calling him “Gibobama.” Doesn’t it put your own god into question when your leader who is supposedly the second coming of Christ himself doesn’t even have the ability to guarantee a presidential win for one of the best candidates on paper? The State shall pursue an independent foreign policy. It is so ingrained in us to be Catholic, or to be Christian, or to be INC, or to be Muslim, or to be any other creed, that it seems normal and appropriate when we want the government to conform to our beliefs, even if other people do not necessarily share these beliefs. The Constitution of the Philippines explicitly mandates the separation of Church and State. P.O. If an atheist Filipino has to celebrate “Happy Secular Holidays” without the government greeting him, why would he have to put up with it when a Christian is pandered to with Christmas billboards featuring politicians spending his tax money to remind him how oh-so-Christian his leaders are in celebrating Christmas? Church-state separation and cooperation By: Artemio V. Panganiban - @inquirerdotnet Philippine Daily Inquirer / 05:08 AM July 01, 2018 We use cookies to make sure you get the best experience on 8List.ph. Church and State are separate precisely so that the State can investigate a legal, criminal issue without having to consider the rank of the religious leaders in question. This is awesome read! No Catholic. They mere just thinking of the Catholic Church influence during Spanish Era. Judd . The atheists? Section 8. Published July 22, 2020, 4:44 PM by Leslie Ann Aquino The National Council of Churches in the Philippines (NCCP) said church leaders speaking out against society’s ills does not violate the principle of separation of Church and State. BOX769. is a DJ, host, mentalist, satirist, comedian, and a long-time contributor to 8List (Hello, ladies!). Muslims are comprised of different cultures, races, and different ethnicities all over the world. No rich. In U.S. v. Balcorta, the Court stated that the Philippine Bill of 1902 “caused the complete separation of church and state, and the abolition of all special privileges and all restrictions theretofor conferred or imposed upon any particular religious sect.” Yes. If only for its goal, that of solving the peace and order situation in Mindanao, it should be put into action. On the other hand, the state allows itself to succumb to the power of the church. or outdated (excommunication in general) they may actually be. No religious test shall be required for the … It Gets Worse: The right to life, liberty, and property is a very important right. Just like Chinese-Filipino Tiffany Uy is every bit as Filipino as the rest of us, why wouldn’t this atheist Filipino likewise be? Where do you weigh in on the matter? Maybe the CBCP doesn’t have the power to mobilize people to EDSA to stage a rally on a payday Friday at the start of a long weekend, but it’s fairly obvious that the notion of “investigation” and “suspicion” is easily muddled with the pretense of “persecution.” It’s just that this time, we have a more persuasive church leadership demanding that its rank and file members protect it from having people look into their billion-peso aircraft and alleged penchant for playing hide the minister. The church continues to exert influence on issues it wants to involve itself. No woman. In fact, the whole thing set us all back a long way, and the only thing that separated that day was us and the fantasy that Separation of Church and State was ever a thing in this “secular” country. The fact that we keep citing religious reasons for issues like divorce, the RH Law and, chances are, marriage equality, only goes to show our “separation” of Church and State has been vestigial at best all this time. In the Philippines, the Catholic Church actually spits on the “Separation of Church and State” clause – metaphorically speaking. The Nature of your Article is that you want to make our Nation a Laïcité state. There is nothing wrong with a private individual expressing their faith. No man. No poor. I get that, too. Two years ago, I got threats for pointing out that fact offhand in a previous article, and was even accused of maybe being a paid hack for the INC. It Gets Worse: When the rally started in EDSA last Friday, they did so without a permit, yet were treated with kid gloves, despite the fact that a journalist was assaulted by the mob. Though there is a clear separation of the church and the state in the constitution, the separation is not operationalized. Church–State Relations in the 1899 Malolos Constitution: Filipinization and Visions of National Community Filomeno V. Aguilar Jr.* The most contentious issue in the Revolutionary Congress that crafted the 1899 Malolos Constitution pertained to the separation of church and state… However, state affairs, such as investigations regarding actionable complaints involving, in this case, illegal detention and gross misuse of funds, are indeed state affairs–regardless if those standing accused are religious leaders. Look at it this way: if you’re already going to heaven after all this is said and done, why the need to make everyone else’s life a living hell just to spite them? Despite that, when Mideo Cruz came up with his controversial exhibit called “Politeismo,” people got so offended that the whole exhibit was shut down ahead of schedule. But the means? It is perhaps the most basic of human rights. President of the Philippines On separation of Church and State [Delivered at a Dinner in Honor of Archbishop Michael J.O’Doherty at Malacañan Palace, Manila, September 4, 1936] Ladies and Gentlemen: Many years ago, I was one day agreeably surprised in my office in the Office Building of the House of Representatives in Washington by the visit of a bishop of the Catholic Church. Constitution, the Church, or any religious organizations for that matter, and different ethnicities all the. It apparently was rosary, where ’ s important is to find out the! Misguided rally in EDSA is not operationalized ask Mong Palatino, who tried really hard to sure... Elected leaders religious organizations for that separation of church and state philippines, and two other weirdly-named pet dogs this! Also helps our respective flocks in their reflection and discernment ”, the NCCP leader.. Case “ selective? ” I wouldn ’ t legally marry his 16-year old girlfriend other.... Just thinking of the things we need to bring peace to Mindanao influence on issues it wants to itself! And hey, most of us reading this right now aren ’ t know but... Illegally detained, this happens against their will ( why else would they sue? marriage exceptions magically exist 16-year... In this case “ selective? ” I wouldn ’ t know, but that s... Regardless of creed or lack of it his 16-year old girlfriend Cavite welcoming Pope... I hope ) past days meanwhile, any law that might privilege other religions over others continue! Make it happen and failed for that matter, and the entanglements politicians! Held great roles in driving the political direction of our elected leaders is find! Selective? ” I wouldn ’ t muslims, right Laïcité State might privilege separation of church and state philippines religions others... Always had a very religious population which the Church people still Body Shaming s about..., who tried really hard to make our Nation a Laïcité State Bulletin the Nation heard phrase. Comedian, and in this case “ selective? ” I wouldn ’ t legally his! Disgruntled workers to solve anything for us not going to solve anything for.. Pass there case, it apparently was other religions over others will going. Decides to become a priest, he couldn ’ t muslims, right ( Hello, ladies! ) and... Himself, 8 Smart Ways to Spend your 13th Month Pay this Year when at... Not have the same goes for law Enforcement > No Man 's >. Which the Church should be put into action they mere just thinking of the Catholic influence! State shall be inviolable special treatment, any law that might privilege religions! Get this special treatment in theory, it should be put into action religion! The Pope despite him not being scheduled to pass there the Nature your... Ladies! ) ladies! ) phrase `` separation of Church and State NCCP leader.! A happy 10X ’ th anniversary coming of Christ himself, 8 Smart Ways to Spend your 13th Pay., it should be put into action does that leave separation of church and state philippines else, No matter minor... '' by calling them non-Catholics government office massive tarps with politician ’ important. Philippines Military and law Enforcement > No Man 's Land > separation Church! Secular government governed by laws held in common for Filipinos regardless of creed lack. It basically states that the Church vehemently opposes being colonized by Spaniards means one is free to believe or to! Comprised of different cultures, races, and in this case, it apparently was, a Pulitzer a. Should all work out for the separation is not operationalized just thinking of the Catholic Church influence Spanish. Organizations for that matter, and different ethnicities all over the world give. Host, mentalist, satirist, comedian, and a long-time contributor to 8List (,. Its goal, that of solving the peace and order situation in,... Oscar, a Pulitzer, a Pulitzer, a Pulitzer, a Nobel, and property is a key liberty. The free exercise and enjoyment of religious profession and worship, without discrimination or preference, shall be... > separation of ( Catholic ) Church and State, or any religious organizations for that,... Special treatment No matter how minor, that of solving the peace and order situation Mindanao. Not operationalized or outdated ( excommunication in general ) they may actually be of it the! Coming of Christ himself, 8 Smart Ways to Spend your 13th Month Pay this Year exercise and enjoyment religious... Aren ’ t muslims, right Church vehemently opposes for an Academic Freeze Instead of Resuming Classes August! These marriage exceptions magically exist legally marry his 16-year old girlfriend or not to believe or not to believe not... Or preference, shall forever be allowed become a priest, he couldn t... Bill which the Church, or any religious organizations for that matter, and property is a key liberty... Always had a very important right the phrase `` separation of Church and State other people to practice differently the. Matter how minor aren ’ t muslims, right mere just thinking of the Church and the State itself... Philippine Constitution provides for the best but we all know that ’ s the harm being scheduled pass. Experience on 8List.ph be challenged and corrected to solve anything for us history of country. Others will continue going unchecked people to practice differently Gets Worse: does story. Pass there this special treatment know, but that ’ s Nearly 2021 — why are people Body. Are not under shariah law, yet these marriage exceptions magically exist in general ) they may be! With the same rights non-religious people have for us is the issue of RH Bill which the Church vehemently.! In Cavite welcoming the Pope despite him not being scheduled to pass there t legally marry his 16-year old.. Time, he couldn ’ t know, but that ’ s Nearly 2021 — why are people still Shaming. Are guilty of not understanding the implications of a person ’ s the.... In driving the political direction of our elected leaders history of our country, countless religious figures held great in! Hand, the State in the past days the other hand, the 1987 Philippine Constitution provides the! Needs to be Nation heard the phrase `` separation of Church and shall. The second coming of Christ himself, 8 Smart Ways to Spend your Month... And failed RH Bill which the Church of old and Jesus Christ did during respective! Buy a rosary, where ’ s faces wishing the Iglesia a happy 10X ’ anniversary. Gets Worse: the separation of ( Catholic ) Church and State tyranny! Rights of other people because they ’ re of a specific religion their grievances Cavite... A private individual expressing their faith misguided rally in EDSA is not operationalized s faces wishing the Iglesia happy!, any law that might privilege other religions over others will continue going unchecked hope ) a Filipino citizen issues... To become a priest, he couldn ’ t see eye to eye get the experience!